Why liquid sweeteners need a recipe adjustment, not just a swap
Granulated sugar is a dry ingredient; honey and maple syrup are liquids that are also sweeter by volume than granulated sugar — using the same volume of honey as sugar would both over-sweeten the recipe and add unaccounted-for liquid, which can make a batter too thin or throw off a bake's structure. That's why the standard conversion uses less liquid sweetener by volume (about ¾ cup honey per 1 cup sugar) and also calls for reducing another liquid ingredient in the recipe (milk, water) by a few tablespoons to compensate for the extra moisture honey itself brings. Honey and maple syrup also both contain natural sugars that brown faster than granulated sugar, which is why recipes using them often lower the oven temperature slightly to avoid over-browning before the inside finishes baking.
Coconut sugar and brown sugar — the simpler swaps
Coconut sugar and brown sugar are both still dry, granular sugars, so neither needs a liquid adjustment the way honey or maple syrup do — they're much closer to a true 1:1 swap. Coconut sugar is slightly less sweet and brings a mild caramel note; brown sugar adds moisture (from its molasses content) and a deeper flavor, which is part of why it's often specifically called for in recipes wanting a chewier texture, like many cookie recipes.
Baking with honey: a typical adjustment
For each cup of sugar replaced with honey, use about ¾ cup of honey, cut other liquid by roughly 3 to 4 tablespoons, and lower the oven temperature by about 25°F to avoid over-browning. Many bakers also add a pinch (about ¼ teaspoon per cup of honey) of baking soda to balance honey's natural acidity. These are starting points rather than exact rules, and a recipe developed with honey in mind will always be safer than converting one written for sugar, especially in cakes.
What sugar does besides sweetening
In baking, sugar also tenderizes, holds moisture, helps browning, and feeds yeast. That is why cutting sugar sharply, or swapping in a non-sugar sweetener, changes more than taste: cookies spread differently, cakes can turn out drier and paler, and bread may rise more slowly. Reducing sugar by about a quarter in many cookie and quick bread recipes usually still works well, but going further generally calls for a recipe designed for it.
Granulated, caster, and powdered sugar
Caster (superfine) sugar dissolves more quickly than granulated and is a fine 1:1 swap by weight; you can make a close approximation by pulsing granulated sugar briefly in a food processor. Powdered sugar contains cornstarch and a very different volume, so it is not a direct replacement in recipes that call for granulated, and you should convert by weight rather than cup if you have to use it.
FAQ
What about stevia or other zero-calorie sweeteners? These vary enormously by brand and concentration — always follow the specific product's own conversion chart rather than a general rule, since pure stevia extract is vastly more concentrated than a sugar-blend product like Truvia Baking Blend.
Do I need to reduce liquid for coconut sugar too? No — coconut sugar behaves like a dry sugar in this respect, unlike honey or maple syrup.